If you’re on the hunt for a mascara that makes your lashes pop without the fuss, you’re probably torn between Maybelline’s Very Black and CoverGirl’s Black mascaras. Both promise to deliver bold, striking lashes, but let’s see which one really delivers when you need it to perform.
| Feature | Very Black | CoverGirl Mascara Black |
|---|---|---|
| Color Intensity | High | Medium |
| Waterproof | ✓ | ✗ |
| Clump-Free Formula | ✓ | ✓ |
| Volume Boost | 2x | 3x |
| Price | $8 | $9 |
| Brush Type | Curved | Straight |
✅ very black Pros
- Intense color payoff for dramatic lashes.
- Waterproof formula holds up against sweat and tears.
- Curved brush aids in easy application and curl.
❌ very black Cons
- Can be difficult to remove without a good makeup remover.
- Volume boost is not as dramatic as competitors.
✅ covergirl mascara black Pros
- Offers impressive volume boost.
- Clump-free application every time.
- Affordable pricing for budget-conscious buyers.
❌ covergirl mascara black Cons
- Lacks waterproof capabilities.
- Color intensity is not as bold as Very Black.
Performance
When it comes to performance, Very Black takes the cake for anyone who needs their mascara to last through a workout or a tear-jerker movie. Its waterproof formula is a true workhorse, making it a solid choice for those with active lifestyles. On the other hand, CoverGirl’s mascara offers a fantastic volumizing effect, but without the waterproof benefit, it may falter if you’re caught in the rain or watching a tear-jerker.
Build Quality
The build quality of both mascaras is impressive, each with its strengths. Very Black’s curved brush is a major win for those who want that added curl and lift with each swipe. It’s a bit of a revelation if you’ve got naturally straight lashes. CoverGirl’s straight brush, while not as fancy, does a commendable job at separating lashes and avoiding clumps, which is ideal for a neat, defined look.
Value
CoverGirl’s slightly higher price might make you hesitate, but if volume is your main goal, it’s worth every penny. You get a lot of bang for your buck in terms of lash volume. However, if you’re after a budget-friendly option that won’t budge under pressure, Very Black is the more economical choice. It’s the go-to for those who need durability without breaking the bank.
Very Black’s waterproof feature is both a blessing and a curse. Sure, it won’t run, but you’ll need a strong makeup remover to take it off without scrubbing your lashes off. CoverGirl’s mascara, while easier to remove, doesn’t have the staying power you’d need for a full day’s wear or a night out.
Our Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
If you’re someone who values intense color and needs a mascara that can withstand a little water, Maybelline’s Very Black is your best bet. It’s ideal for users with an active lifestyle or those who simply can’t resist a good cry without looking like a panda. On the flip side, if you’re all about that va-va-voom volume and don’t mind touching up throughout the day, CoverGirl’s Mascara Black is the way to go. It’s perfect for anyone prioritizing lash volume over waterproofing.
Is Very Black suitable for sensitive eyes?
Yes, but it’s always best to do a patch test first. Its intense formula may not sit well with everyone.
How does CoverGirl’s mascara fare with contact lenses?
It’s generally safe for contact lens wearers, but as always, test it out to ensure it doesn’t irritate your eyes.
Which one is longer-lasting?
Very Black is the more long-lasting option due to its waterproof formula, ensuring it stays in place longer than CoverGirl’s version.
